Hey, I love polls. And polls like this one, where I can't just tick a box but have to think first which box I tick and why are even better. :D Keep the polls coming!
OK, if we're going with the most probable I'd say during Season 2, after ELAC. Underage is rather unlikely. Kids may be kids, and yes, they were raised kind of isolated, but they both went to school and had enough possibilities to experiment there. Plus, there is the age gap. Four years is a lot in puberty. In Season 1 there was still some distance between them because Sam couldn't settle and wanted to leave again, so no. John's death threw them both off their feet and left them struggling, so I think if anything would have happened/started it would have been then. Born out of desperation, and then they just kept going.
Hey, thank you! I think polls should be easy and fun, but not brainless.
And you are now my new BFF because you voted the same way I did! It's not that everyone else is WRONG (which they are!) but I surely wasn't expecting so many people NOT to agree with me!
I love underage because I'm whacked like that, but while I can see fooling around at a young age, I can't see it being anything with staying power. Like, if they had a circle jerk as teens, they would have forgotten it as soon as it was over and moved on. So yeah, I'm with you. John's death was a major catalyst!!
Hi new BFF. *waves* You know what, I'm so lame that I had to go to the Urban Dictionary and look up BFF.
I'm having trouble with underage, which is kind of sad because it makes me miss out on quite a few fics. I don't mind them jerking off together as teens, but I can't read full-on sex unless Sam is at least sixteen. And even then I get uncomfortable when Dean does the topping, not because I like it better the other way around (which I do!), but because I still see a power imbalance at this age. Sigh. I'll have to keep missing out I guess.
Yeah, I've had to look it up a few times myself, so don't feel bad! Thank goodness for the Urban Dictionary. (UD)
So...you like underage fic but draw the line at under 16? I can understand that. I'm sure there's tons of fics that match your criteria; you might check specifically with SPN Storyfinders and put your call out. Or...imagine that the love Sam and Dean get from each other is the ONLY love they will ever truly have.
I once read Plutogirl10's "Into the Woods" and had no idea when I was reading it that Sam was 15...I just took it as regular wincest. So sometimes you can't tell....
Hey, a request on storyfinders is a good idea. I might make one later on. At the moment I have this really weird craving for J2 high school/boarding school AUs (I know, what has gotten into me?!)and I need to get over that first.
No. You don't need to get over it, you just need to SATISFY the hankering! Did you post your request yet? I went and posted one for "Sam possessive of Dean" because that's what flavor I wanted. : D
No request yet. The pesky RL kept me so busy and offline this week that I didn't even manage to watch the new episode, let alone satisfy the high school craving. *grumbles* I have a lot of catching up to do this weekend. Possessive!Sam is yummy.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
no subject
OK, if we're going with the most probable I'd say during Season 2, after ELAC. Underage is rather unlikely. Kids may be kids, and yes, they were raised kind of isolated, but they both went to school and had enough possibilities to experiment there. Plus, there is the age gap. Four years is a lot in puberty. In Season 1 there was still some distance between them because Sam couldn't settle and wanted to leave again, so no. John's death threw them both off their feet and left them struggling, so I think if anything would have happened/started it would have been then. Born out of desperation, and then they just kept going.
no subject
And you are now my new BFF because you voted the same way I did! It's not that everyone else is WRONG (which they are!) but I surely wasn't expecting so many people NOT to agree with me!
I love underage because I'm whacked like that, but while I can see fooling around at a young age, I can't see it being anything with staying power. Like, if they had a circle jerk as teens, they would have forgotten it as soon as it was over and moved on. So yeah, I'm with you. John's death was a major catalyst!!
no subject
I'm having trouble with underage, which is kind of sad because it makes me miss out on quite a few fics. I don't mind them jerking off together as teens, but I can't read full-on sex unless Sam is at least sixteen. And even then I get uncomfortable when Dean does the topping, not because I like it better the other way around (which I do!), but because I still see a power imbalance at this age. Sigh. I'll have to keep missing out I guess.
no subject
So...you like underage fic but draw the line at under 16? I can understand that. I'm sure there's tons of fics that match your criteria; you might check specifically with SPN Storyfinders and put your call out. Or...imagine that the love Sam and Dean get from each other is the ONLY love they will ever truly have.
I once read Plutogirl10's "Into the Woods" and had no idea when I was reading it that Sam was 15...I just took it as regular wincest. So sometimes you can't tell....
no subject
no subject
no subject